Left side advert image
Right side advert image
Super banner advert image
Subscribe to Print Monthly's RSS feed

Enter your email address here to sign up for our weekly newsletter

Conway exposes con artists ripping off industry

In a move to stop his industry peers falling victim to con artists, the managing director of Venture Banners, Scott Conway, exposes the scam targeting our industry.

Article picture

Con artists are specifically targeting wide-format printers, so if a new customer sounds too good to be true, they just might be

We’ve all laughed at the email from the wealthy African Prince offering a cut of his millions in return for help to get those millions out of the country. ‘Who an earth would fall for that?’ we snigger as we hit the delete key. Unfortunately that is the easily spottable tip of a very large iceberg of cons.

Have you ever wondered what would happen next if you responded to one of these scams in the positive? What’s the scammer’s next play? At what point would they try to relieve you of your hard earned dough? It is reported that fraud cost small- to medium-sized businesses in the UK around £9.2bn in 2013. This is frankly an astounding sum of money, and I would suggest that the scum bags are getting away with it.

Worryingly there are a number of scammers out there that seem to be targeting printers in general and large-format printers in particular. Out of interest and for research purposes, we at Venture Banners followed several scams through and though most are shallow and easily identified some are quite ingenious.

The shipping scam

We had a quotation request for 100 banners with the words ‘Arms to the Poor’ printed in black text on a white background. The broken English contained in the e-mail and the content of the banner (we’re guessing that should have read ‘Alms’) immediately raised suspicions, however we were interested to see what happened next, so we responded with a ludicrously high price, which unsurprisingly was accepted straight away.

It all sounded terribly familiar. His face was ashen as we explained the scam to him


The ‘client’ then proceeded to give us his credit card details with instruction to take an additional £1,000, which we were to pay to his shipping company, as the banners were going out of the UK and would be picked up by Agorie Shipping. Bank details were of course included for Agorie.

We did some checks. The credit card was genuine and would go through for the full amount including the shipping costs. So what could possibly go wrong?

Well, quite a lot actually. We had already tracked the IP address of the original email to Ghana which raised some red flags and basic enquiries found that the credit card being offered belonged to a gentleman who resided in Romford. More red flags.

So what would have happened if we had gone through with the transaction? Well it is simple really, once the gentleman in Essex discovered his card had been used fraudulently the money would be clawed back from us by the card company. We would of course be unable to recover the one £1,000 paid by us legitimately to the shipping company, which incidentally further investigations showed did not actually exist.

The conmen would have ‘earned’ £1,000 for just a couple of e-mails. Easy and lucrative. We would have followed the scam through, seen what we needed to see, now all that was left to do was inform the poor man in Romford his credit card details were being bandied around the web by a man in an internet café in West Africa.

The funny thing was, we were having lunch with an industry friend just a few short weeks after we had played this out and over lunch he told us of this amazing deal he had put together on a large banner order. It all sounded terribly familiar. His face was ashen as we explained the scam to him. Unfortunately he had paid the shipping company and predictably the credit card payment to him was clawed back. No one ever came to pick up those banners.

Credit card fraud is on the rise, and today’s sophisticated scammers not only steal identities, but can get you to inadvertently participate in ripping off the victim




The overpayment scam

This is brutally simple but very effective and seems to be organised in this country. Someone requests a quote from you for ten roller banners. They like the quote and ask for a pro-forma invoice. You are paid. In fact, with online banking you can see the money sitting in your account.

Only by mistake they’ve over paid you by £1,000. Realising their error they phone you, ‘admin error!’ they say and ask if you wouldn’t mind transferring the overpayment back to them. Obviously they are new customer and have just spent a lot of money with you, so your customer service reflex kicks in. ‘Of course’ you say ‘I’ll do it right now’. Wrong!

If you look very closely at your bank account, you will notice that even though the customer’s money is showing in your balance, it is not actually cleared funds.

Guess what happens next…yep you guessed it, the money paid in by the customer is actually a cheque paid in over the counter and is destined to bounce in five days’ time, giving them ample time to fleece you. You are then left £1,000 out of pocket, and if you are really unlucky ten roller banners down as well.

We have managed to save several people falling victim to this scam because the scammers are lazy and use the same artwork for the roller banners every time. We were explaining this scam to one of our trade customers who had been targeted and had asked us to produce the roller banners for him, but he was convinced it was a genuine order, he had spoken to the customer who was a ‘really nice bloke’ right up until the e-mail came in ‘we’ve overpaid you, would you mind...’ which happened whilst we were actually on the phone to him. He was obviously disappointed to ‘lose’ a lucrative order, but thankful he was not a grand out of pocket.

There are numerous ways these swindlers can try to steal from you so the Met Police and Barclays have produced a booklet outlining how to avoid becoming a victim of the scammers. You can download it on the link below via our website and as Shaw Taylor used to say; ‘Keep your eyes peeled’.

Web link for download:
http://www.venturebanners.co.uk/download/misc/little_book_big_scams_business_edition.pdf


Print printer-friendly version Printable version Send to a friend Contact us

1 comments, displaying first: 

Sign in:

Email 

or create your very own Sign Link account  to join in with the conversation.


Avatar

Andy March   View users other comments

Wednesday, 17 Feb 2016 14:00 GMT
User since 17/02/2016

We had a similar scam attempt in November last year. 28 pavement signs to Belarus - eh? As Scott did we looked at the email address (non corporate,) Russian based - not Belarus, and he wanted to use his nominated carrier. We over-quoted and he didn't even question the price. I guess that it was just his bad luck to pick (probably) the only person who runs a UK sign company but also visits Belarus one a year (for a children's Chernobyl charity) Since 2007 I've built up a small - but well connected - group of friends over there, including the British-Belarus Chamber of Commerce. It look them less than 24 hours to confirm my suspicions, the supposed retail chain and the carrier were both non-existent. Nowadays it isn't only "let the buyer beware" - the supplier needs heighted awareness as well!